Mojo #4 : Direct participation Mock up on video
In my last post I underlined the distance existing between the document, the comment (participation), and the tool website propose.
Why I spoke about that, because, I think good tool to participate is one of the key to improve journalism.
During is talk last week Mohamed Nanabhay present the big challenge for news channel to be in front of the hudge flow of data to process in realtime. And the problem to filter when you open the input process. If filter is important as I said in my first and second MOJO post with this idea of repetition rate, it’s impossible to filter raw data if you don’t have good metadata on it.
And the best way to have metadata is to open the process and cristalise it by a good participation process.
To present this paradigme of direct participation (contribution) with example I propose few case study and mock up :
- first example will be on the relation of video and comment.
- the second will be on the relation between a webpage and comment.
Video and comment on Youtube
The picture below present the repartition between document and participation, place to read, place to write, and the “ligne de flotaison” (I don’t know the term in english but the major end of the browser windows). The video is an intervention during the EG8 from Jeremie Zimmermann about hadopi a french law to censor the web . We can see a the bottom of the picture there is 4 pages of comments.
Unformtunatly all this comment are not timestamped and addressable by an URI, so we can’t use it to address a special offset of the video. But If you have a lot of rush uploaded by people like in the nice project Aljazeera Creative Commons Repository you have to find a way to index deeply video to find what you want. It’s for that make a link between comment and video offset will probably enrich you capabilities to filter and find the relevant information.
What we propose is to make a tool of comment participation more closer to the document. Below a draft mock up to reduce the distance between document and comment and enhance metatdata production. It could be a popchorn.js module to make a light client to produce hypervideo but for that it’s urgent to have a standart format as we try to think with Julien Dora, Mark Boras, Nick Doiron :
1/ When the user rollOver the timeline, the slider show an extension to select a segment of time by dragging and dropping. After this action the user add a comment or tag … here the purpose is to make a deep link between the video and the participation.
2 / After that the segment can be show ( with a lot of segment we can imagine a system to couple that with a system of peer reviewing, and editorialisation ) And it’s for deep research.
3 / Inspired by Sputnick website we can enhance the relation between segment of video by making a UI to allow user to link the segment of one video to an other segment or an other video, or URL (by a form) .
4 / With a visualisation like the polemic timeline of comment user can see the “hotspot” of the social activities and his browsing experience is enhance by this information. Below You can see Tree peak of comment during the video and use it as an indicator.
Sound Cloud understand this and make a really interesting interface for comment by reducing the distance between the user and the object of participation but not perfect because not really readable if their is to much comment :
Cover image by CC BY NC ND Some rights reserved by Judy **